In New York City, twenty-two years ago, the most serious mistake
the United States justice system can make became a reality. A man was falsely convicted of murder. After spending much of his life in prison, on
Thursday, David Ranta walked out of a New York City courthouse as a free man.
In
an attempted diamond heist, a rabbi was shot and killed. The original target, a jewelry courier, escaped
unscathed. Ranta was charged with second-degree
murder and later sentenced to 37 ½ years to life in prison.
Since
Ranta’s trial, multiple pieces of evidence and information have come to
light. A widow accused her late husband,
who was a suspect early in the investigation, of committing the murder. In addition, a major component of the
prosecutor’s case, Ranta being picked out of a lineup by a 13 year old boy,
turned out to be a fraud. Recently this
individual came forward, stating that he was told to “pick the guy with the big
nose.” Finally, an inmate that gave his
testimony at the trial and provided evidence against Ranta admitted that he
fabricated his statement in order to appear cooperative to aid with his own
case.
In
my opinion the rush to judgment and deception shown by the detectives that handled
this case is terrible. It is inexcusable
and cost 22 years of a man’s life.
http://www.cnn.com/2013/03/21/justice/new-york-conviction-overturned/index.html?hpt=hp_bn1
I agree with you Harrison. This is no way that the justice system should pass its verdict. Thorough investigation must be done to prevent this from happening. Peoples' lives are at hand when it comes to these things. If you rush a judgement, you have a higher probability to making a mistake, as shown by this case. I think that prosecutors as well as detectives should check and double check their information to make sure that they do not have the wrong person convicted. After all, everyone is guaranteed a fair trial in court and if this is false, then what becomes of our justice system?
ReplyDeleteAlthough I agree with both Nick and Harrison on this, in the defense of the courts, sometimes the family of the victim can push the investigation to convict someone in order for them to get closure. I think it's important to look from the perspective of the detectives that handled this case
ReplyDelete